Genuine Leather or Synthetic Leather Mouthpiece Case: Which is Better?

When browsing the Internet in search of a reliable and beautiful mouthpiece pouch for your brass instrument, you may find many options, varying in style, color, and price. Despite many available genuine leather models, people may still opt for budget-friendly faux leather cases in an attempt to save money. However, they may often feel frustrated after some time of use, as their expectations aren’t met. In this article, we will compare genuine leather and synthetic leather mouthpiece cases to help you select the best one with realistic expectations. 

What are Synthetic Leather Mouthpiece Cases and Why Are They Good? 

These are accessories made from several types of leather: polyurethane leather (PU), polyvinyl chloride leather (PVC), or microfiber leather. What makes faux leather mouthpiece cases so attractive to customers is their soft texture, which visually mimics genuine leather, along with multiple color options and affordable price.  

While microfiber leather has a texture close to real leather and can offer resistance to wear and tear, PU and PVC leather tend to crack and peel over time, especially when affected by high and low temperatures or exposed to active use. Faux leather can’t offer the same breathing characteristics as genuine leather, which makes it less comfortable for delicate devices. 

During recent years, the interest in synthetic leather has increased due to ethical considerations. The manufacturing process of synthetic leather excludes animal products, however that doesn't necessarily mean that you do less harm to the environment, as many synthetic leather versions (especially PVC) are not biodegradable. Moreover, they can release toxic chemicals over time.

What are Genuine Leather Cases and Why Are They Good? 

These are cases made from real animal hide that has been tanned and properly treated to offer a reliable cover for your mouthpieces. To craft these accessories several types of leather may be used. For instance, to produce trumpet mouthpiece holders, MG Leather Work uses two types of genuine leather: Crazy Horse and Detroit leather, each offering unique characteristics and visual attraction. 

• Crazy Horse leather mouthpiece holders stand out from the rest due to their vintage design, warm colors, and unique patina, which appears over time and makes the accessory even more unique and authentic. Crazy Horse is a waxed leather with excellent water-resistant properties that increases the lifespan of the holder.

  

• Detroit leather mouthpiece holders draw attention with their smooth and pleasant-to–touch texture that makes the accessory look classy and exclusive. Due to the tanning process, based on using natural vegetable extracts and oils, Detroit leather is available in a wide range of colors, from black to ivory. 

  

Both types withstand frequent use and travel, making them perfect for musicians with busy lifestyles and regular tours. 

Comparison Between Faux and Genuine Leather Mouthpiece Holders

Now let’s take a closer look at how these two leather holders differ from each other. 

Closure

Faux leather cases typically feature the cheapest zippers that can result in snagging, breakage, and corrosion. Over time, especially when affected by moisture, these holders can become difficult to open. Moreover, with this closure, your case is always at risk of accidental opening and leaving your mouthpieces unprotected or even lost. 

Genuine leather cases feature high-quality YKK zippers that stand for durability and easy, smooth functioning regardless of how often you open and close them. They are reliably attached to the holder, complementing their neat and luxurious design. 

Low-quality holders are typically equipped with one-slider zippers, while high-quality genuine leather cases offer two-slider zippers, allowing for convenient access from both directions and providing better security. Two-slider zippers also offer partial opening and reduce stress on the zipper.

Stitching 

Budget-friendly cases may frustrate you with their uneven, poorly sewn edges that can spoil the overall appeal, even if their texture closely resembles genuine leather. 

Genuine leather mouthpiece holders are made with attention to the smallest detail. They are well-stitched and neat. 

Interior 

Both types of holders offer soft lining inside and separate slots for each mouthpiece, however, cheaper cases may lack an additional pocket for accessories, where you can keep oil, brushes and other small essentials. 

The fabric inside may also vary in quality. Genuine leather holders are sewn inside with premium fabric, while cheaper faux leather cases are not stitched and feature cheap fabric. 

Durability 

Thanks to waxing and tanning, genuine leather lasts longer compared to synthetic leather. When properly cared for and conditioned regularly, genuine leather is less prone to cracking and deteriorating, while synthetic leather cracks and peels over years, especially when exposed to heat, moisture, and friction.

Breathability 

One of the key characteristics of genuine leather is that it allows for airflow, preventing moisture buildup. Synthetic leather can trap humidity, increasing the risk of mold and corrosion on the mouthpiece.

Aesthetic

Synthetic leather can perfectly mimic genuine leather, however it can’t mimic the same smell and feel. Moreover, synthetic leather may have a plastic, chemical, or even fishy odor because of the amines. That can spoil the overall impression, even if the case looks comparatively appealing.

Some musicians, especially those who pay attention to each detail in their style, find synthetic cases less attractive and luxurious. They value genuine leather as it has a natural, unique grain and soft feel that improves with time if properly cared for. 

Conclusion 

Synthetic and genuine leather mouthpiece cases aren’t the same, since they differ in durability, texture, aesthetic, breathability, quality of stitching, closure, and interior design. While you can save money by buying faux leather cases, they can’t offer the same level of reliability and a long lifespan as those made of genuine leather. By purchasing genuine leather mouthpiece cases, you invest in your reputation, comfort, and the safety of your devices. 

Our offerings aren’t limited to mouthpiece holders. Explore more useful leather accessories for brasswind and woodwind instruments on our website.

We have already mentioned that faux leather is cheaper, however, you can always save money on genuine leather products by taking advantage of our SPECIAL OFFER.